JKOwners Forum banner

1 - 14 of 14 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
573 Posts
I would have expected a much higher difference in torque failure than 500 ftlbs from the breathless warnings expressed by the narrator. 6900lbft/axle failure of the ARB vs 6400lbf/locker failure of the imitation. So we have a 7% difference in additional torque for the ARB. I wonder how much more expensive the genuine ARB is over the Chinese version?

BTW-- Since you published this the Chinese website is not responding. hmmmmmm

I occasionally buy Harbor (Horrible) Freight Chinese tools because for the most part they are "good enough". I can buy a set of Y tools from HF versus a similar product through Grainger or from RIGID or SNAPON for (a lot of times) 5-10 times "Y". Depending on whether I feel I will use Y more than once or twice and the amount of abuse I will subject the Y set to, I pick HF and spend the savings on more things elsewhere..... recognizing the utility is "good enough". So my second & third set of "Y" tools is often HF or Walmart or Kmart/Sears knock offs than SNAPON or KOBALT or whatever Home Depot is hawking at the moment. People can spout "better than X" all they want, but when the casual user (me) goes looking for "Good enough", price makes a difference.

/rant
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,341 Posts
I would have expected a much higher difference in torque failure than 500 ftlbs from the breathless warnings expressed by the narrator. 6900lbft/axle failure of the ARB vs 6400lbf/locker failure of the imitation. So we have a 7% difference in additional torque for the ARB. I wonder how much more expensive the genuine ARB is over the Chinese version?

BTW-- Since you published this the Chinese website is not responding. hmmmmmm

I occasionally buy Harbor (Horrible) Freight Chinese tools because for the most part they are "good enough". I can buy a set of Y tools from HF versus a similar product through Grainger or from RIGID or SNAPON for (a lot of times) 5-10 times "Y". Depending on whether I feel I will use Y more than once or twice and the amount of abuse I will subject the Y set to, I pick HF and spend the savings on more things elsewhere..... recognizing the utility is "good enough". So my second & third set of "Y" tools is often HF or Walmart or Kmart/Sears knock offs than SNAPON or KOBALT or whatever Home Depot is hawking at the moment. People can spout "better than X" all they want, but when the casual user (me) goes looking for "Good enough", price makes a difference.

/rant
It isn't so much about "good enough" it is theft of intellectual property.

BTW, every time you choose China over the US, you make a future enemy of the US stronger.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
573 Posts
It isn't so much about "good enough" it is theft of intellectual property.
Sorry, I did not pick up that vibe from the video... it was too much "Look how much better OUR product is than that cheap Chinese knock-off" rather than "Oh, look. Someone stole our design isn't that terrible"

Imitation is supposed to be the most sincere form of flattery. And ARB has been around for a loooong time, I am sure most of the patents surrounding the product have expired which leaves them no alternative but to compare against product quality.... which apparently the video is doing. When the patents expire the I.P. such as it is, is free game for ANY person with the cash to copy and resell.....


BTW, every time you choose China over the US, you make a future enemy of the US stronger.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Guilt trip does not come into play no matter how much most people would agree with that statement. $$$ does. When I can go to HF and buy my "good enough" tool for $5.99 that would cost me $20 from a U.S. manufacturer, (which is -only- ~3x the U.S. price) I give no consideration whether the tool is from China, Taiwan, Japan, Korea, India, South Africa, Canada, or any of a host of other exporting countries. Don't know, don't care. It is $14 less than the other tool which means more money for me to spend on other toys.

So YOU want to spend all your cash on U.S. tools because it makes you righteous? Fine, your prerogative. My brother in law won't shop at Walmart because when they moved in, his favorite mom-n-pop clothing store could not compete. Mom-n-pop is a favorite fable of the way things used to be, but for one, I do not enjoy paying $50 for a shirt I can buy for $20 at Walmart (or Target, Sears, J.C. Penney, Kohls, etc.). Again, yours and his choice. But on a budget, I go for affordable.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
803 Posts
I would have expected a much higher difference in torque failure than 500 ftlbs from the breathless warnings expressed by the narrator. 6900lbft/axle failure of the ARB vs 6400lbf/locker failure of the imitation. So we have a 7% difference in additional torque for the ARB.
Yeah but per video the axle shaft and not the locker broke with the ARB so the ARB may have held up to much more.

IMO the title of this thread is wrong since "fake" would mean that the Chinese made lockers are boxed, labeled/branded and marketed as ARB lockers which appears not to be the case.
So IMO they are reversed engineered knock-offs that are boxed under their own label and with it allow the purchaser to decide if they want to buy the lower cost knock off or the real deal.

Oh and don't underestimate Chinese products because they can produce top notch quality if the sector is managed accordingly and still do it with a lower cost than most other countries.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,738 Posts
I wonder what the knockoff is. The only other air locker I'm familiar with is the Yukon.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,580 Posts
So forget for a minute about whether intellectual property has been compromised or monetary savings or whether we're morally compromised for buying Chinese knock-offs or whatever.

When you buy a Harbor Freight tool, the worst that can happen is that it doesn't work right or fails. Who cares, you go get another one.

When you're asking 100 percent of your porker wheeling rig on a nasty obstacle, I don't want a knock-off in my axle period. It's not as simple as getting another. It could be a nasty disabling trail break with an expensive tow, downtime and having to cough up the cash all over again. Not worth it.

Nothing hard to understand about that, ARB FTW.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,652 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Like it or not a broken axle shaft is an easier trail fix than a busted carrier..... buy what the fuck you want but dont be pissed when it explodes and you have a heafty repair bill
 
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
Top