Hey guys, I just recieved a new tire cover from All Things Jeep and thinking it's a tad big. My Jeep still has the 255/75/17 spare and the cover they recommend is a 33'' cover. Doesn't fit as tight as I like them to. Think this thing will grow,shrink or stay the same after a while? Not terrible but not great. I really don't know if a size smaller will go over the tire. What to do, what to do? Keep it or return it?