Think I'll be doing this before Jeep Beach this weekend... a consolation prize for my smitty fenders not working out! So I've been thinking about the idea of matching one side to the other (I'm a recovering cabinet maker) and I think I've got it. I'll lay newspaper or cardboard if I can find some over one side, trace what I want and cut it to make a template. Then I'll use the template to mark the one fender, then flip it over to mark the other

I think I'll probably pull the fenders off to cut them, I want the cut to die into the vehicle clean and I don't want a slipped blade to mess it up. I have a sawzall but in this case I'm thinking my jigsaw will offer a more controlled cut and I have much better blades for it. A little clean up with a belt and I bet they'll look good (I'm thinking the belt sander will allow me to polish the edge and get around the "piping" treatment). I'm lost as a mechanic but this is more akin to woodwork so I'm excited to tackle it! Hope the template idea helps somebody, I'll post pics when and if I get it done.