JKOwners Forum banner
21 - 40 of 87 Posts
Just replaced mine last night, easy. Thanks for the info Ron.
 
Discussion starter · #24 ·
What are the symptoms of having a bad valve?
A bad PCV valve may or may not show symptoms.
Rough running/idle, increased oil consumption, are among the possibilities.

Inspection is required to see if it is functional.
Remove it and look for general condition, broken spring, and see if the cone inside will rattle up and down when you shake it.
 
I am ready to do this and dont have any symptoms that i can see.... how much is this valve? should i be changing it?


Awesome write up BTW!
 
It looks like Napa has them for around $10. And the Owner's manual tells what interval to check it at.

Come to think of it...I haven't checked mine since I've owned my Jeep. Might be worth looking at next time I do maintenance.
 
well they say check it at 30K... here is 30k... so i figure ill just change the bastard out... and for ten bucks why not!
 
well they say check it at 30K... here is 30k... so i figure ill just change the bastard out... and for ten bucks why not!
That's what I was thinking too. (I'm at 60k)


Can you post a NAPA part number?
If you put in your vehicle on their site, and then narrow it down to PCV - it gave me "CRB 29555" as the only option for mine.
 
...just finished this up on mine. It was a bitch to get that damn thing out of there. :pissed: The zip-tie trick didn't work for me (kept slipping off) and so in the end, I had to stand on my engine compartment with a pair of vise grips and pull it out, completely destroying the old one in the process.

However...this write-up was definitely helpful. Couldn't have done it without it. Thanks Ron! :bounce:
 
...just finished this up on mine. It was a bitch to get that damn thing out of there. :pissed: The zip-tie trick didn't work for me (kept slipping off) and so in the end, I had to stand on my engine compartment with a pair of vise grips and pull it out, completely destroying the old one in the process.

However...this write-up was definitely helpful. Couldn't have done it without it. Thanks Ron! :bounce:
Mine was the exact same way. I had a new one to put in, regardless of the old one's condition.
 
PCV Valve replacement

I just replaced the pcv valve on my 2009 JK, as soon as I turned it on I noticed a rough idle and a few seconds later the check engine light came on. Took it for a short drive and it had a hard time accelerating. I put the old one back since I figured it looked fine just in case the new one wasn't right for it, though it looked exactly the same. Any suggestions?
 
^^^^ Maybe you did not properly reinstall a spark plug wire??? A stopped up PCV loop will not cause the issues you listed. My bet is the code you threw was cyclinder misfire. When you put the old valve back in you seated the wires properly.
 
...just finished this up on mine. It was a bitch to get that damn thing out of there. :pissed: The zip-tie trick didn't work for me (kept slipping off) and so in the end, I had to stand on my engine compartment with a pair of vise grips and pull it out, completely destroying the old one in the process.

However...this write-up was definitely helpful. Couldn't have done it without it. Thanks Ron! :bounce:
Did my second one Sunday. SO MUCH EASIER with the coil-pack out of the way! I used a set of ignition wire boot pliers on mine. Took a bit of convincing, but it eventually popped out with no damage.
 
I just replaced the pcv valve on my 2009 JK, as soon as I turned it on I noticed a rough idle and a few seconds later the check engine light came on. Took it for a short drive and it had a hard time accelerating. I put the old one back since I figured it looked fine just in case the new one wasn't right for it, though it looked exactly the same. Any suggestions?
^^^^ Maybe you did not properly reinstall a spark plug wire??? A stopped up PCV loop will not cause the issues you listed. My bet is the code you threw was cyclinder misfire. When you put the old valve back in you seated the wires properly.
Nope... same here, I got the valve from the dealer parts dept. and installed it myself. Got the same symptoms as fdavid a few days later. Thinking it couldn't be related I took it to the dealer for service. It threw a code "internal vacuum leak". They replaced the PCV and all was good again. I have no idea what I did wrong unless it wasn't fully seated and slipped out of the seat allowing too much air in.
 
I got mine from the dlr... Did the install and removal myself and haven't had a problem since! And that was just about 6k miles ago!


Sent via your mom on a tricycle wearing a paper crown from Burger King
 
...just finished this up on mine. It was a bitch to get that damn thing out of there. :pissed: The zip-tie trick didn't work for me (kept slipping off) and so in the end, I had to stand on my engine compartment with a pair of vise grips and pull it out, completely destroying the old one in the process.

However...this write-up was definitely helpful. Couldn't have done it without it. Thanks Ron! :bounce:

This^^^^ What a mutherfucker. Ended up doing exactly that. Still didn't get rid of my light though.
 
i like this how to for placement of the valve and all the other steps other then the zip tie! haha mayhbe it was the old zip ties i used but all of them broke.... finally took some pliers to it and yanked it out! i had the new one in hand anyway so i didnt care.
 
21 - 40 of 87 Posts