JKOwners Forum banner

1 - 20 of 26 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I took my 2007 unlimited to the Lake Norman Jeep to get the oil changed and for them to check out a ticking noise that Ive been hearing from the engine for a week. They call me back and say I need a NEW ENGINE.

I manage a BBQ restaurant right down the road (Mac's Speedshop) and money is tight these days.
I bought this Jeep used from Keith Hawthorne Ford in Charlotte, and didnt get a warranty. So im screwed.

I kind of blacked out after he said "New Engine" and didnt get the particulars. Tomorrow am I am talking to them and seeing what my options are. I love my jeep and I feel like somebody punched me in the face.

Any opinions on where to take it for a second opinion?
I should have gotten a warranty. :bawling:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,414 Posts
I took my 2007 unlimited to the Lake Norman Jeep to get the oil changed and for them to check out a ticking noise that Ive been hearing from the engine for a week. They call me back and say I need a NEW ENGINE.

I manage a BBQ restaurant right down the road (Mac's Speedshop) and money is tight these days.
I bought this Jeep used from Keith Hawthorne Ford in Charlotte, and didnt get a warranty. So im screwed.

I kind of blacked out after he said "New Engine" and didnt get the particulars. Tomorrow am I am talking to them and seeing what my options are. I love my jeep and I feel like somebody punched me in the face.

Any opinions on where to take it for a second opinion?
I should have gotten a warranty. :bawling:
I think there is a 3.8L for sale in the for sale section on here for 700$.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,230 Posts
Used 3.8l is a much better idea than a new short block from the dealer. I'd buy the used engine and drive your current one until it quits or gets much worse.

Drop it to the shop with the engine and tell them to swap it out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,277 Posts
Used 3.8l is a much better idea than a new short block from the dealer. I'd buy the used engine and drive your current one until it quits or gets much worse.

Drop it to the shop with the engine and tell them to swap it out.
that ^ IF it truely needed to be replaced

When is it ticking? Does the ticking change with the rpm of the engine?

Cracked exhaust manifolds produce a ticking noise, but usually go away once engine/exhaust warms up.

Definitely get a 2nd opinion and I wouldnt mention what the dealer told you.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter #5 (Edited)
Thanks a lot for the advice. I will research my options. If any of you are in the area of Charlotte or Lake Norman come by and I'll get your first beer.

-Drew
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,851 Posts
How long ago did you buy it? Your state may have a law to cover "lemon law" type of situation (I am not saying it would be covered under the Lemon Law regs tho).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Take it to keffer jeep over on independence and have them look at it. I have found that LKN jeep is not the most trustworthy dealership in town to say the least.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
87 Posts
Also, don't tottaly count out Chrysler. I have a 2008 and am the second owner. If your milage isn't to much you might be able to rationalize with Chrysler. They where willing to help me out. Go ahead and give them a call.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
456 Posts
Just jumping in as I love Macs - are you the red rock one that sits out back some???

I have the white JKU that I spoke to you about one time when I was in there with my family.

P.S. - Macs is so much more than a BBQ joint - trust me everyone if you get a chance - go...

I would try Keffer to see what they say...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,283 Posts
Run from Lake Norman as fast as you can. I will never step foot in there again. They voided the warranty on my old dodge after the 2nd transmission blew and it cost me over 5K. Then for some dumb reason I went there to buy a new JK and they talked me into leaving a deposit on one that they had. Well long story short I bought my current Jeep at Keffer and it took me 6 months to get my $500 deposit back from them. They also took advantage of another board member here almost as bad as me.

Take it to Keffer. I think they are the best dealer in the Charlotte area. :beer::beer:

Oh yea Mac's rocks. I haven't been to your location but I have been to South Blvd. and the one off Tryon a bunch of times.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
I talked to LKN Jeep, and they said they couldn't find a used engine, and I would be looking at $4,700 in charges/labor for the engine they would be able to get.

I asked him what exactly they found wrong with my engine and he stated that while he didnt look at it, his Tech said their 'theory' was it was bad Wristpins and something about a Cam.

Now I can tell you how many pounds of Brisket, Pork and Beer Can Chicken it takes to feed a party of 200,and how long to smoke each meat, but nothing about Engines.

If they haven't taken anything apart, how can I justify spending that much on a theory? I told him thanks, and I'll be there Tuesday morning to pick it up and take it elsewhere for a second opinion.

Going to Keffer tomorrow and dropping Jeep off.
Also looking up Used Engines on my own.:shaking:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
85 Posts
A Guy up here got his motor replaced for a bit over 2k... cdn... if I remember correctly. Also apparently a bad lifter in these motors sounds like a knock in the bottom end... so I'm told by the tech I know who works for a dealer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
157 Posts
I talked to LKN Jeep, and they said they couldn't find a used engine, and I would be looking at $4,700 in charges/labor for the engine they would be able to get.

I asked him what exactly they found wrong with my engine and he stated that while he didnt look at it, his Tech said their 'theory' was it was bad Wristpins and something about a Cam.

Now I can tell you how many pounds of Brisket, Pork and Beer Can Chicken it takes to feed a party of 200,and how long to smoke each meat, but nothing about Engines.

If they haven't taken anything apart, how can I justify spending that much on a theory? I told him thanks, and I'll be there Tuesday morning to pick it up and take it elsewhere for a second opinion.

Going to Keffer tomorrow and dropping Jeep off.
Also looking up Used Engines on my own.:shaking:
A used 3.8 shouldn't be hard to find. Do some research and have a good independent shop do the swap if it comes to that. I had some ticking that was more like a thumping on my 2008 JK and came to find out that the dealership was putting 10W30 in when I had my oil changed!? These guys should know better!! Anyway, put the right oil in and the noise is gone and so are my worries!!


My father in law works at Rick Hendrick's City Chevrolet in Charlotte and we always visit from Atlanta. I will definitely be checking out the food and your rig next time we come up!!


Make sure you find a good place for second opinion. We would help at our shop If we were closer!! Good luck!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter #14
Hey ya'll thanks a lot for the replies.

When I bought it used, I took it to get the oil changed for the first time and they said the wrong oil was being used by the previous owner. Now the correct oil is in there, does it take long to have the correct oil to go through the system? Would it cause an annoying ticking sound? Is this something that will pass? Or eventually blow up and leave me stranded on a dirt road?

Regardless, I'm going to find other shops to look at it.

Thanks for the help.
And if you are ever in the area, come see me, and come hungry/thirsty. I got you.
-Drew
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
55 Posts
The wrong oil was used? I'm assuming they mean the wrong viscosity, but I'm unsure how they could tell this during the oil change...unless it was ATF or something. Where did you get this oil change?

If it was an oil issue that caused damage, the damage is most likely already done, and putting the "correct" oil in there will not fix it, but may prolong the life. If it was ticking from under pressurized lifters, then the correct oil would fix it. As others have stated though, I would definitely get a second opinion. Ticking can be caused by LOTS of things, and to assume wrist pins is a bit of a stretch. Also, to an untrained ear, ticking and knocking sound similar. Knocking = $$$.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
If I were you I would take the Jeep to Tarheel 4wd in Charlotte and ask for Steve. He knows Jeeps very well and could probably diagnose your problem for you for just a few bucks by doing simple things like a compression test and checking for exhaust leaks, pulling a valve cover on the side with the tick and inspecting the rockers, etc. Your problem could be major or it could be a really cheap and easy fix. BEWARE! Dealers swap old parts for new until the problem goes away. They don't fix anything anymore. It is in their best interest that you buy a new engine from them. Steve is not trying to make a living swapping out $5000 engines so he hasn't got a stake in what you ultimately decide to do. He'll give you an honest unbiased opinion and if a new engine is in your future he might even be able to help you locate a good used one. He doesn't sell engines though. BTW I am not affiliated with Tarheel. Just a satisfied customer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,450 Posts
I took my 2007 unlimited to the Lake Norman Jeep to get the oil changed and for them to check out a ticking noise that Ive been hearing from the engine for a week. They call me back and say I need a NEW ENGINE.

I manage a BBQ restaurant right down the road (Mac's Speedshop) and money is tight these days.
I bought this Jeep used from Keith Hawthorne Ford in Charlotte, and didnt get a warranty. So im screwed.

I kind of blacked out after he said "New Engine" and didnt get the particulars. Tomorrow am I am talking to them and seeing what my options are. I love my jeep and I feel like somebody punched me in the face.

Any opinions on where to take it for a second opinion?
I should have gotten a warranty. :bawling:

:pissed: Holy Crap! I have an 2009 with 31k and this just happened to me! It's at the dealer right now getting a new engine under warranty. I'm sorry yours isn't covered. However, their is something terribly wrong with these minivan engines (besides under powered). I'm thinking oil pump!

My engine "tick" started on the top end (like it was starved for oil). Once that was replaced, there was a "tick" in the bottom end. Dealer can't or didn't say how it happened. I was told that the manufacture would determine the actual cause when the engine was shipped back. They just told the dealer to replace the engine.



BTW....... Wrong oil? No way!!! Not unless you used axle grease! Seriously, I'm pretty religious about maintenance and always used factory specified oil on every vehicle I've owned.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,011 Posts
that ^ IF it truely needed to be replaced

When is it ticking? Does the ticking change with the rpm of the engine?

Cracked exhaust manifolds produce a ticking noise, but usually go away once engine/exhaust warms up.

Definitely get a 2nd opinion and I wouldnt mention what the dealer told you.
x2. I have yet to hear a JK that doesn't "tick." Mine's been ticking for about 30,000 mi. The engine still seems to run just fine.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,283 Posts
If I were you I would take the Jeep to Tarheel 4wd in Charlotte and ask for Steve. He knows Jeeps very well and could probably diagnose your problem for you for just a few bucks by doing simple things like a compression test and checking for exhaust leaks, pulling a valve cover on the side with the tick and inspecting the rockers, etc. Your problem could be major or it could be a really cheap and easy fix. BEWARE! Dealers swap old parts for new until the problem goes away. They don't fix anything anymore. It is in their best interest that you buy a new engine from them. Steve is not trying to make a living swapping out $5000 engines so he hasn't got a stake in what you ultimately decide to do. He'll give you an honest unbiased opinion and if a new engine is in your future he might even be able to help you locate a good used one. He doesn't sell engines though. BTW I am not affiliated with Tarheel. Just a satisfied customer.
I usually don't do this but please steer clear of Tarheel 4WD. I was screwed pretty good by them and I know of a number of others that were also. I wouldn't say anything if I didn't have first hand knowledge. I'm not going to get into the story but I can assure you that I will never recommend them to anyone. If you want to find an independent place head over to NC4x4.com and post up over there and you will probably have a half dozen or so in the greater Charlotte area offer help. :beer::beer:

Hell if you want I'll take a listen to it for you and tell you how serious I think it is. I live right down in Huntersville. If you want to come down PM me.

Jeremey
 
1 - 20 of 26 Posts
Top