JKOwners Forum banner

1 - 20 of 22 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Long story short, some dipshit made a U-turn in front of me on Sunday and I smacked him pretty good with my driver side front tire. The impact caused my lower control arm bracket on the axle to pretty much shear off, and in the process bent the driveshaft and smacked the yoke into the oil pan punching a hole in the process. I had it towed to a jeep dealership (not on the insurance company's approved list) and they did their own assessment which came out to about $7k in damage. I am not sure if that is just for parts, or parts and labor, but regardless that is a decent amount of money. They want to replace the entire front housing, driveshafts, ball joints, oi pan, and a few other things. I am thinking that if I can get a few of these parts upgraded at a cheaper price while they are being paid for I am going to try and do it. My question is, has anyone had experience with this type of thing and what can I expect? Thanks ahead of time!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Yes, have experience with a similar situation.

We ended up getting the insurance check cut directly to us instead of having it fixed at a shop. Ended up getting a pair of rubicon axles for far less than a new mopar front axle would have been. It can be done. The stick to all this, is whether or not you have a lien and if your lienholder and insurance company will play ball with you.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
Yeah the jeep is not paid off, but how is that relavent? Sorry I am new to this so I am not quite following. The insurance company I understand and I know I'm in for a fight with them, but the lender I don't understand.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Yeah the jeep is not paid off, but how is that relavent? Sorry I am new to this so I am not quite following. The insurance company I understand and I know I'm in for a fight with them, but the lender I don't understand.
because sometimes lendors require that vehicle be fixed by a certified shop because technically, they own it. In the event its a total loss, which it doesn't sound like, the insurance check would go directly to the lendor, either in full and the lender would cut you back the difference, or often times when gap insurance isn't purchased, you'd be stuck with a remaining balance on a totaled vehicle you no longer have access to. All very general scenarios here, and chances are if its not totaled your insurance company is the only party you'll be dealing with, but stranger things have happened.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
Ok I gotcha. That makes sense. Yeah it isn't totalled and I have only dealt with the insurance company so far. I am going to assume that is all I will deal with (It is at a jeep dealership though), although I am sure I am in for a fight. I am hoping I can negotiate something with the dealership where I can put something other than mopar parts into it. $4080 for their 44 is outrageous and I know I can get a badass axle for 75% of that. I guess I'll have to wait and see.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
Ok I gotcha. That makes sense. Yeah it isn't totalled and I have only dealt with the insurance company so far. I am going to assume that is all I will deal with (It is at a jeep dealership though), although I am sure I am in for a fight. I am hoping I can negotiate something with the dealership where I can put something other than mopar parts into it. $4080 for their 44 is outrageous and I know I can get a badass axle for 75% of that. I guess I'll have to wait and see.
Going through this right now. I got rear ended by a Hyundai Tiburon going 40-50+. Not my fault, so I'm going through his insurance. So far we're at $12,000 in damage, including my rear axle. Despite the fact act that my shop charges $110 per hour for everything and the insurance is only covering that for mechanical (which is very little of the overall labor), I was able to upgrade the front bumper, have a take off rear bumper put on (didn't find a rear I liked at the time), pro comp wheels, 35" tires, 2.5" lift kit, new spare tire carrier (TF HD hinged adjustable), and Magnaflow exhaust. I'm only out about $1,600 and I'm filing a diminished value claim that I'm hoping covers all that. If I get more, I'll get my new rear bumper or put it toward re-gearing. It is a lot of back and forth with the insurance, but my lender hasn't been involved at all, and I'm going through a Jeep customs shop. Not Jeep.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
Oh, and they are covering $52 per hour for everything else.

And it ended up being a four car pileup by the time it was all said and done. Mine was the first one bit by the dumbass Tiburon.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
Feel free to post away or PM if you have questions. I'll happily share my experience. My Jeep has been in the shop for one month already. I've had a Hyundai Santa Fe for the entire duration of the time so far.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
Going through this right now. I got rear ended by a Hyundai Tiburon going 40-50+. Not my fault, so I'm going through his insurance. So far we're at $12,000 in damage, including my rear axle. Despite the fact act that my shop charges $110 per hour for everything and the insurance is only covering that for mechanical (which is very little of the overall labor), I was able to upgrade the front bumper, have a take off rear bumper put on (didn't find a rear I liked at the time), pro comp wheels, 35" tires, 2.5" lift kit, new spare tire carrier (TF HD hinged adjustable), and Magnaflow exhaust. I'm only out about $1,600 and I'm filing a diminished value claim that I'm hoping covers all that. If I get more, I'll get my new rear bumper or put it toward re-gearing. It is a lot of back and forth with the insurance, but my lender hasn't been involved at all, and I'm going through a Jeep customs shop. Not Jeep.
Damn, that's a much worse situation than I'm in. I am just going through my insurance even though it was his fault and then they can recover the money from his insurance. I'm glad to hear that you were able to upgrade the replacement parts. I am hoping for a Teraflex 44 or a currie 44 as a replacement even though I know the dealer will try to sell me their stuff. That and some upgraded driveshafts and I will be a happy camper!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
@JeepGirl83 have you had to fight with the insurance company at all?
Well... I was going to go through my insurance with a no fault claim because his insurance was slow to respond. But then I got estimates from both agencies and pitted them against one another. His insurance was actually covering most of the parts at a higher cost than mine, so I went with his, but I had to rough them up a bit on labor costs. They only wanted to pay $85 mechanical and $50 for everything else. My insurance was covering $110 mechanical, so I made them match. Then I got everything else to a whopping $52. Other than that, they've been anxious to write checks or send payment to my shop EFT with little hassle.

They even offered to pay me for lost wages (even though I used a sick day, so that's all I lost) and a whopping like $150 for "pain and suffering" just because I decided to get checked out at the local urgent care. I didn't even try to fight for that... they just offered it.

The real kicker will likely be in the diminished value claim I intend to file. I've googled and seen all the ways they calculate it, so I suspect they will try to beat me down on that. I'm honestly just hoping to break even with all my upgrades (which means I need at least $1,600 for diminished value). They won't talk diminished value until repairs are done though.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
Feel free to post away or PM if you have questions. I'll happily share my experience. My Jeep has been in the shop for one month already. I've had a Hyundai Santa Fe for the entire duration of the time so far.
my condolences
Right?! It's slightly better than a CAR, but not by much. I'm anxious to get my Jeep back after more than a month without it, to say the least.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
The real kicker will likely be in the diminished value claim I intend to file. I've googled and seen all the ways they calculate it, so I suspect they will try to beat me down on that. I'm honestly just hoping to break even with all my upgrades (which means I need at least $1,600 for diminished value). They won't talk diminished value until repairs are done though.
as someone who does it for a living every day, appraising trades, financing, etc at a new car lot (Ford and Lincoln), you probably stand to get far more than that. GENERALLY, when a major accident is shown on carfax, ROUGH trade on NADA is the absolute ceiling I'll put into a vehicle when its traded. More often than not, that's more than several thousand difference to average, and that's my ceiling. Just food for thought.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
The real kicker will likely be in the diminished value claim I intend to file. I've googled and seen all the ways they calculate it, so I suspect they will try to beat me down on that. I'm honestly just hoping to break even with all my upgrades (which means I need at least $1,600 for diminished value). They won't talk diminished value until repairs are done though.
as someone who does it for a living every day, appraising trades, financing, etc at a new car lot (Ford and Lincoln), you probably stand to get far more than that. GENERALLY, when a major accident is shown on carfax, ROUGH trade on NADA is the absolute ceiling I'll put into a vehicle when its traded. More often than not, that's more than several thousand difference to average, and that's my ceiling. Just food for thought.
Well, that's bad news for if I ever trade it in, but good news for the short term. Do you have any recommendations on who I would get to put together an estimate before and after the accident to give to insurance? My shop can't do it, and I've called the used car department at my local Jeep dealer and haven't heard back. No clue who to go to beyond that. Thanks for any help you can provide!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Well, that's bad news for if I ever trade it in, but good news for the short term. Do you have any recommendations on who I would get to put together an estimate before and after the accident to give to insurance? My shop can't do it, and I've called the used car department at my local Jeep dealer and haven't heard back. No clue who to go to beyond that. Thanks for any help you can provide!
You can get used car values offline yourself. Just show the difference between excellent to good to fair to rough. Id personally go from excellent to rough if the jeep is well cared for. If not, good to rough. They'll look at the undamaged portion, the overall cleanliness of your interior, etc to calculate all that. You have to be realistic in your estimation of the condition your jeep was in before the accident. But you can rest assured, since its been in a major accident, the ACV (actual cash value) of your jeep will fall at or below rough trade now.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
So yesterday I found out that the insurance company approved $8500 worth of repairs. I talked to the dealership about replacing the MOPAR axle, driveshafts, and BJ's with aftermarket, which is cheaper. Is there a need to tell the insurance company what I am doing or can I just work this out with the dealership? Thanks guys/girls, sorry for all of the questions.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
So yesterday I found out that the insurance company approved $8500 worth of repairs. I talked to the dealership about replacing the MOPAR axle, driveshafts, and BJ's with aftermarket, which is cheaper. Is there a need to tell the insurance company what I am doing or can I just work this out with the dealership? Thanks guys/girls, sorry for all of the questions.
I wouldn't tell the insurance company. I don't know if they CAN, but I would be afraid that they would reduce my claim amount to only cover the after market parts I needed for repairs. That would prevent me from getting my additional upgrades, obviously.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Discussion Starter #19
I asked my insurance company what their policy was and was told I can put whatever I want on there. Whatever the dealership and I agree to. The dealer is a little butthurt about me choosing aftermarket parts instead of their MOPAR stuff though. Oh well!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
333 Posts
I asked my insurance company what their policy was and was told I can put whatever I want on there. Whatever the dealership and I agree to. The dealer is a little butthurt about me choosing aftermarket parts instead of their MOPAR stuff though. Oh well!
Glad they don't care and glad you're getting what you want! Do you have an ETA on when you'll get it back yet?
 
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Top