I have a 1" body lift and running 35's on 17 inch procomps. Like you, I wanted a good all-around tire, I do alot of highway miles so I wanted something fairly quiet. I ended up with Yokohama Geolander AT-S. They look pretty good and are great in the wet and dry, haven't had them in snow yet but the reviews were great and they have lots of siping that leads me to believe they'll be good. They're also very quiet. For on-road performance I'd put them up against the BFG AT KO, at much lower cost. I've only done dirt trails so I cannot attest to their ability off-road. I'm pretty much a mall-crawler, and got the jeep (for now) to have something with 4 doors since I just had a son : ) Maybe when he's old enough for rougher play I'll do some more with it.