My stock flares have held up quite nicely over the past year. They have been subject to tires stuffing and plenty of boulders that have all but tore the fenders off. Three of the four fender were held on by sheet metal screws because the clips holding them on broke
off. The right front took a good hit out at johnson valley and some how cracked the liner in half. May have been from the tire but not sure.
I installed xenon narrow flares . I currently don't have the liners on but I think I like having them on so I'm looking for just the one fender.
So get those tube fender installed and send the liner my way.